Star Wars

Dec. 20th, 2015 06:01 pm
erilyn: (cheese)
[personal profile] erilyn
Um, so yeah, I'm still around, hi!

I don't have a terribly appropriate icon at the moment for this. But I need to record my reactions a little. I saw The Force Awakens this morning with my sister and [ profile] iibnf (and many children, it was a 9:30am session, but pretty well-behaved, thankfully). Haven't really read any reviews/discussions yet, so this might be totally repetitive to what everyone is saying. And my thoughts are very scattered, if I try to make them coherent I'll never get around to posting.

I'm not really sure how I feel? I went in very unspoiled, and I'm mostly glad about that. I think?

It was entertaining. Much better than the prequels (setting a low bar, with apologies to the one prequels fan I know *g*).

But I'm jealous of people who loved it, because I didn't really. The first half was better than the second, when it became inescapable that they weren't just mirroring/paying homage, they were basically remaking the plot of A New Hope (well, and Return of the Jedi, but there was a lot of overlap there anyway). The secret message on the droid found in the desert was one thing, but did it have to be a bigger, badder Death Star attacked by X-Wings and a ground force? After visiting a cantina? And all the other plot beats they hit?

I don't understand why it is Resistance (allied with the Republic) v the First Order, and not the Republic v the First Order? And was that Coruscant that got exploded?

Wait, Lupita Nyong'o was playing Maz? I liked the character but that seems a bit of a waste of casting her. Speaking of female characters, why would Han and Finn leave Captain Phasma alive (by chucking her down a garbage chute) when they have no qualms about killing any other First Order soldiers? Seems like a cheap way of keeping her around til we can actually see Gwendolen Christie at some point.

And did they cast someone unattractive who looks nothing like Harrison Ford and Carrie Fisher to throw people off about him being their son? Early on I was wondering if Kylo Ren was going to be Luke (and map to find him was actually going to be something about rescuing him from Darkside) but decided that was too obvious. ETA: remembered another funny moment - the two storm troopers backing away and going the other direction to get away from his tempter tantrum.

Anyway, being very negative but I didn't hate it. I like Rey and Finn. I could believe their interactions and motivations (yep, more shade being thrown at prequels). I liked how she kept rescuing herself, and when I was going to be mad about her being knocked out of fight with Kylo Ren, it was her fight that was the big one.

I like Poe Dameron (pity his last name wasn't Antilles). I liked cameos from old friends like Nien Nunb (or someone of same species) and Admiral Ackbar! (Meanwhile, the Greg Grunberg cameo had me rolling my eyes.) I am vaguely intrigued to find out more about Kylo Ren's turn to darkside (seemed like they were worried about him even before Luke started training him?)

But really, my negative reactions are really about the big three - Luke, Leia and Han. I was worried that Han and Leia were gonna be separated, though at least the loss of their son was a decent reason for that. But Luke being like every other Jedi and becoming a hermit and letting the galaxy burn after fucking up? And abandoning his sister? Not happy, I hope the next movies come up with a better reason than he was moping.

And I just knew that Han would die once he confronted his son, and my biggest indictment about my reaction to this movie - I didn't cry. Though thinking about how there won't be anymore Han/Leia scenes, and we'll never see Luke and Han interact? I'm pretty fucking bummed.

(Sorry, it has to be said - Leia only lost her ex. Chewbacca lost his life-partner.)

Argh, I dunno, when I look at what I've written, it sounds way more negative than I thought I felt. I'm planning on seeing the other movies (disgusted to hear that Ep 8 is 18 months away? Fuck off Abrams, Peter Jackson wrote the rules for trilogy movies now, stick to it), but I'm not sure I'll rush to see this one again at cinema.

Now, is there any Finn/Poe fic? What? I'm asking for a friend...I'm seriously thinking of pulling out the first Timothy Zahn trilogy though.

Date: 2015-12-20 09:50 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
*looks around* what is this place??

I listened to a review yesterday and apparently it wasn't Coruscant - the New Republic is still around, they are all out on the edge of space where there is still a fight going on. That is what was explained in this review anyway.

Lupita was great, but yeah I agree, a bit of a waste casting her.

I didn't cry about Han but I was definitely emotional about it. I really didn't see it coming, but I really should have, because Star Wars.

I also rolled my eyes at Grunberg showing up, but of course he was going to be in it.

Date: 2015-12-27 07:25 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
Yeah, apparently they did name check the system where the planets got exploded during the movie, but I guess I either missed it or didn't know if that system was supposed to contain Coruscant.

Date: 2015-12-21 08:38 am (UTC)
ext_1792: (xena)
From: [identity profile]
I almost cried at Han, i'll be honest

I also was like, woah he looks nothing like his parents, but then I was like, ohhhh but he does look like his sulky mcgrandparent anakin skywalker

and you are right that temper tantrum and the stormtroopers backing off was funny, and it felt like a modern kind of joke that the original trilogy and prequels wouldn't have done right

i really liked when rey was like LET GO OF MY HAND!

Date: 2015-12-27 03:00 am (UTC)
ext_2569: text: "a straight account is difficult, so let me define seven wishes" image: man on steps. (tvd help I'm alive (Caroline))
From: [identity profile]
I also was like, woah he looks nothing like his parents, but then I was like, ohhhh but he does look like his sulky mcgrandparent anakin skywalker


Date: 2015-12-27 07:24 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
Yup, he is definitely Anakin's grandson...alas!

Date: 2015-12-27 07:06 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
I feel like people are really grading on a curve. "Much better than the prequels" is both true and not that high a bar. *g*

The new characters were great and very charming, and I agree entirely about them having believable motivations and character arcs.

I was SO MAD about Han. When he said to Leia that he was gonna bring Darth Emo home, I leaned over to L and said "in a box!" Yeah.

Hate everything to do with Luke, for the reasons you stated. Please God let them come to their senses on that one. My favourite EU Luke is Zahn's, who never loses his head obsessing over Jedi-related stuff but is instead a pragmatic problem-solver.

And omg the Resistance thing bugged me SO MUCH. Why the hell are they the Resistance? What's happening with the actual Republic and the actual massive fleet they would undoubtedly have? How big is the First Order's territory? What happened to the remnants of the Empire? I could probably find out a lot of that stuff from supplementary materials, but why should I have to?

Date: 2015-12-27 07:29 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile]
I think one of the most important details re salvaging Luke's storyline is possibly my biggest question re the movie (cause it ties into so much): what is the timeline since RotJ? Specifically, how long since Ben went dark side (and how old is he now), and how long has Luke been missing?

I had a bad feeling when they wiped the EU only to immediately start pumping out lots of comics and books and tv shows that are canon. They should be nice add-ons but not required homework to understand the movies.


erilyn: gabe and mikey's hips (Default)

December 2015


Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 26th, 2017 09:34 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios